Eidnani Capital · Midwest residential

Real estate I'd put my own money in. Because I do.

Eidnani Capital sponsors small residential acquisitions in Midwest markets we know cold. Cash-flowing from day one, financed conservatively, and structured so we only win when our investors do.

Get in touch → View the strategy
Operating portfolio
04properties
Across IL · OH
Sponsor co-invest
10% minimum
Real money, every deal
Preferred return
7.5% annual
To investors before sponsor
Target investor IRR
~22% net
Stabilized · 5-7yr hold
"
Real estate is the most reliable long-term wealth-building vehicle ever invented. It cash-flows, it appreciates, it amortizes, it shelters taxes — and unlike stocks, banks will lend you 80% of the purchase price at a fixed rate for thirty years. The only catch is access.
Most people can't buy a $270K rental property. But they can own a meaningful piece of one — alongside an operator who knows the work and puts real capital in next to theirs. That's what we do.
01 · The thesis

The Midwest is the most operationally rational residential market in the country.

Rent-to-price ratios in our target submarkets remain at or above 1% — a threshold that has effectively disappeared from coastal and Sunbelt markets. Institutional capital is largely absent below 20 units, leaving a structural gap for disciplined operators with local knowledge.

We are not chasing appreciation. We underwrite to in-place cash flow with conservative assumptions, finance with fixed-rate DSCR debt, and treat appreciation as upside. Where the deal supports it, we use a BRRRR-style approach to recycle capital after stabilization.

The edge is in the operations and the underwriting. We have built proprietary tooling — automated FMR-driven rent comps, refinance triggers, and live portfolio tracking — that gives us a faster, more rigorous read on every deal we touch.

"We are not chasing appreciation. We underwrite to in-place cash flow, finance conservatively, and treat appreciation as upside."
Underwriting discipline
Every deal must work on day-one stabilized rents in a flat-rent, no-appreciation environment. We model 3–4% appreciation in projections — below long-run averages — because conservative underwriting protects investors. This is how you survive cycles.
Skin in the game
10%+ of the equity in every deal is the sponsor's own money. We win when investors win. We lose when they lose. The incentive structure is the message.
02 · Why the Midwest

The data behind the thesis.

Four macro tailwinds are converging on Midwest residential right now: a structural housing shortage, a collapsed construction pipeline, the end of Sun Belt outperformance, and the start of a rate-cut cycle. Each strengthens the thesis on its own. Together they make the next 5–7 years a structurally favorable window. The market-by-market data below shows where this thesis lands on the ground.

3.7M
unit national housing shortage
Freddie Mac estimates the US is short 3.7 million housing units relative to demand. The deficit is structural — not cyclical — and has barely moved despite 5.8M new units built since 2020. The shortfall is most severe in entry-level rental product, which is exactly our buy box.
Freddie Mac, Q3 2024
−74%
multifamily starts vs. 2021 peak
Multifamily construction starts have collapsed since 2022 as financing dried up. Apartment deliveries projected to fall from ~500K (2024) to ~300K (2027) — a decade low. Existing rental product gains pricing power as the new-supply pipeline thins.
CBRE Research, 2025 Outlook
+3%
Midwest rent growth, 2024
Cleveland and Columbus both posted 3%+ rent growth in 2024 — 3× the 1.0% national average — with Cleveland projected at 3.2–5% through 2025. Meanwhile Sun Belt markets are correcting after overbuilding: Austin rents down 3.5%, Phoenix and Denver down ~1.7–1.9%. The regional inversion is exactly what sponsors hope for after a Sun Belt-led cycle.
MMG · CBRE · TheGuarantors, 2025
↓ rates
Fed cutting cycle underway
The Fed has signaled continued rate cuts through 2026. Lower rates compress cap rates (lifting property values), reduce mortgage costs (improving cash flow on refinance), and pull buyers off the sidelines. We're acquiring at the top of the rate cycle — every basis point lower from here is upside.
Federal Reserve · forward guidance
"
Columbus, Indianapolis, and Seattle are the only three of the top fifteen fastest-growing US metros sitting outside the Sun Belt. The other twelve trade at materially higher prices for materially lower rents.
By market
Active
Plainfield, IL
Will County · Chicago suburbs
StrategyGrowth / Cash-flow
Population growth (5yr annualized)
+2.5%
Home price appreciation (5yr ann.)
~5.5%
Rent growth (2024 annualized)
+3.5%
Metro population (Will County)
713,000
Median household income
$144,000
Premium suburban market driven by school district demand. Pulls Chicago professionals out of the urban core. Strong appreciation paired with consistent rental absorption — Plainfield's median home value has more than doubled since 2000.
Active
Cleveland metro, OH
Cuyahoga County · Seven Hills
StrategyCash-flow
Population growth (5yr annualized)
~0.0% (stable)
Home price appreciation (5yr ann.)
~9.0%
Rent growth (2024)
+3.0% (3× national)
Metro population
~2.1M
Anchor capex inflow
$1.7B (Clinic + S-W)
Cash-flow play, not a growth play. Cleveland's edge is yield: rent growth at 3× the national average plus a supply-constrained market. Anchored by Cleveland Clinic ($1.1B Neuro Institute) and Sherwin-Williams ($600M HQ).
Pipeline
Columbus, OH
Franklin County · Actively sourcing
StrategyGrowth / Cash-flow
Population growth (5yr annualized)
+1.0% (2× national)
Home price appreciation (5yr ann.)
~9.1%
Rent growth (2024)
+3.0% (3× national)
Metro population (2025)
2,242,028
Permit shortfall (2024)
10,474 issued / 19,000 needed
Severe undersupply meets rising demand: 45% short of housing units needed annually. Anchored by Intel's $20B fab, OSU, JPMorgan Chase. Ranked 13th-fastest-growing US metro — one of three non-Sun-Belt entries in the top 15.
Pipeline
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County · Actively sourcing
StrategyGrowth / Cash-flow
Population growth (5yr annualized)
+1.0% (4.1% since 2020)
Home price appreciation (5yr ann.)
~8.9%
Rent growth (2024–25)
+2.5–3.5%
Metro population
1,925,000
BoA Institute ranking (Q4 '25)
#1 fastest-growing US metro
Named fastest-growing US metro by Bank of America Institute (Q4 2025) — outpacing every Sun Belt city for two consecutive quarters. Eli Lilly's $13B Boone County investment + IU Health's $4.3B hospital build are anchoring sustained job growth.

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau Vintage 2024 Estimates (released May 2025); FHFA House Price Index Q4 2025 (5-yr appreciation data); Freddie Mac Housing Supply Shortage Estimate (Q3 2024); CBRE U.S. Real Estate Market Outlook 2025 — Multifamily; Federal Reserve forward guidance; TheGuarantors Multifamily Supply Report (2025); Columbus Region Press Release (April 2026); MMG Real Estate Advisors 2025 Cleveland, Columbus & Indianapolis Forecasts; Bank of America Institute "On the Move: U.S. Migration Patterns" (January 2026); BIA of Central Ohio 2024 Housing Permit Report; Indiana Business Research Center / IU Kelley School of Business; World Population Review (Plainfield, 2026); NeighborhoodScout Plainfield Real Estate Data (2026); City-Data.com Plainfield IL profile.

03 · Buy box

What we buy.

Markets
Cleveland · Chicago suburbs (active)  ·  Columbus · Indianapolis (pipeline)
OH · IL · IN
Asset type
Single-family rentals & 2–4 unit small multifamily
SFR · 2-4U
Price range
At or below replacement cost; rent-to-price ratio at 1.0% or higher
$150K – $400K
Financing
DSCR loans, 30-year fixed, 80% LTV standard
80% LTV
Hold period
Long-term hold with strategic refinance to recycle capital
5–7 years
Strategy levers
Stabilized buy-and-hold · Light value-add · BRRRR where deal supports
3 plays
Target returns
~7.5% stabilized cash-on-cash · ~22% projected IRR over 5–7yr hold
7.5% / 22%
Sponsor co-invest
Real skin-in-the-game on every transaction
10%+
↑ What we don't do
Heavy rehab / flips New construction Out-of-Midwest markets Single-tenant commercial Short-term rentals Speculative land
04 · Investment terms

How sponsorships are typically structured.

3.1
7.5%
Preferred return
Investors are paid first, every year, before the sponsor sees a dollar of profit. Unpaid pref accrues forward.
3.2
80/20
Profit split
Of profits above the preferred return, investors keep 80% and the sponsor takes 20%. We only win when investors win.
3.3
10%+
Sponsor co-invest
The sponsor commits real capital alongside investors on every deal. Aligned incentives, every transaction.
05 · Operating portfolio

Track record from the personal portfolio.

Eidnani Capital is a sponsorship vehicle. The properties below are from the principal's personal real estate portfolio, operated independently and used here to demonstrate the operating discipline applied to sponsored deals.

Faulkner Court — Plainfield, IL
Deal 1 · Stabilized · Jul 2024
Faulkner Court
Plainfield, IL · 60544
Cash-on-cash
8.2%
Equity gain unrealized
+88%
5-yr IRR target
23.4%
Oak Tree Lane — Plainfield, IL
Deal 2 · Stabilized · Feb 2025
Oak Tree Lane
Plainfield, IL · 60586
Cash-on-cash
6.7%
Equity gain unrealized
+72%
5-yr IRR target
19.1%
Crescent Ridge East — Seven Hills, OH
Deal 3 · Stabilized · Sep 2025
Crescent Ridge East
Seven Hills, OH · 44131
Cash-on-cash
7.4%
Equity gain unrealized
+43%
5-yr IRR target
22.1%
Crescent Ridge West — Seven Hills, OH
Deal 4 · Refinanced · Nov 2025
Crescent Ridge West
Seven Hills, OH · 44131
Cash-on-cash
10.4%
Equity gain unrealized
+46%
5-yr IRR target
22.3%
NOTE:   Equity gain measured from initial cash invested to current equity (market value less remaining mortgage). 10-yr IRR target is a forward projection assuming conservative rent growth and modest appreciation; not a guarantee or realized return. Past performance does not predict future results.
06 · The principal

Founder & operator.

Photo · Headshot
Arnav Eidnani
Founder & Principal
Based Cleveland, OH
Portfolio 4 properties · IL · OH
Education Ohio State University
Entity Eidnani Realty Investments LLC

I own and operate four cash-flowing rental properties across Plainfield, IL and Seven Hills, OH through Eidnani Realty Investments LLC. Combined cost basis is roughly $1.05M; current market value is approximately $1.18M+ — about $135K of unrealized appreciation across the portfolio, alongside positive monthly cash flow on every deal. All properties are financed with fixed-rate DSCR loans at conservative leverage and underwritten to operate profitably even at flat rents.

I'm 20 years old, a student at Ohio State, originally from Cleveland. I started investing in real estate in the summer of 2024 using capital I earned through stock trading. Doing this at twenty rather than forty isn't a credential gap; it's a multi-decade time advantage.

What you can expect: conservative underwriting (every deal must work on day-one cash flow, no appreciation assumed), aligned skin in the game (10%+ of every deal is my own capital), active communication (quarterly written updates, full P&Ls, no surprises), and the willingness to say no to deals that don't pencil.

07 · Example deal · Faulkner Court

What this actually looks like.

The terms only mean something when you see them on a real property. Below uses Faulkner Court's actual purchase price, financing, rent, and operating costs to model how a sponsored deal would work.

Faulkner Court — Plainfield, IL
Illustrative · Real property, not a current offering
Faulkner Court
Plainfield, IL · 60544 · Acquired Jul 2024
Purchase
$270,000
Financing
$216K · 7.25%
Total raised
$62,000
Investor capital
$55,800
Sponsor co-invest
$6,200 (10%)
Monthly rent
$2,825
The monthly cash flow, line by line
Line item
Monthly
Annual
Gross rent
$2,825
$33,900
− Property tax
($535)
($6,420)
− Insurance
($67)
($800)
− HOA
($85)
($1,020)
− Maintenance reserve 4%
($113)
($1,356)
− Vacancy reserve 3%
($85)
($1,017)
− Property management
($100)
($1,200)
Net operating income
$1,840
$22,083
− Mortgage P&I 7.25% / 30yr
($1,473)
($17,676)
Free cash flow
$367
$4,401
Cash-on-cash return:   $4,401 cash flow on $54,000 cash invested
8.15%
Of that cash flow: investors receive the first 7.5% pref ($4,185/yr), then anything above splits 80/20 investor/sponsor.
Two ways to exit at year 5
Note on appreciation assumption

Projections below assume 4% annual appreciation from acquisition. We model conservatively for two reasons: (1) it protects investors if macro conditions don't cooperate, and (2) it lets the deal work on its underwriting alone. For context, Faulkner Court's unrealized appreciation has been ~7.9% annualized (purchase $270K Jul 2024 → current market value $310K), well above the 4% modeled. The property has not been sold or refinanced — these are mark-to-market gains.

Macro factors that could support outperformance over a 5–7 year hold: a normalization in interest rates would reduce mortgage costs and typically lifts residential pricing; persistent housing supply shortages in our submarkets continue to constrain new construction; population and employment growth in our active markets (Plainfield IL, Cleveland metro) remain positive. None of these are guarantees — but they are reasons to underwrite conservatively rather than aggressively, and let upside emerge from operations rather than from forecasting.

Property value at year 5 (4% appreciation from $270K purchase): $328,000. Loan balance: ~$203,000. The structure supports either a clean sale or a cash-out refi that returns capital while keeping investors in the deal long-term.

Option A · Sell at Yr 5
Sell the property
Clean exit. Investors receive capital back plus 80% of the gain. Deal closes; LP dissolves.
Sale price (yr 5)
$328,000
− Selling costs (6%)
($19,710)
− Loan payoff
($203,860)
Net proceeds
$104,930
Capital back to all members
$62,000
80% of remaining gain → investors
$34,340
5yr cash flow received:
~$12,210
Plus exit proceeds at sale:
~$40,385
Total per $25K invested:
$52,595
Multiple · IRR:
2.10x · ~16.0%
Option B · Refi at Yr 5
Refinance & continue holding
New loan returns most capital tax-free. Investors keep their stake on a smaller capital base; the deal continues compounding through year 10.
New loan (75% of $328K)
$246,370
− Old loan payoff
($203,860)
− Refi closing costs
($6,160)
Cash extracted
$36,355
Investor pro-rata share (90% of raise)
$32,720
Remaining investor capital in deal
$23,080
Per $25K returned at refi:
$14,660 tax-free
Plus prior 5yr cash flow:
~$12,210
Capital still working:
~$10,340

WHY REFI MATTERS:   Refi proceeds are loan proceeds, not sale proceeds — they are not taxed. Investors get most of their capital back tax-free, keep their ownership stake, and continue earning future cash flow and appreciation. Real estate's compounding engine.

If you choose Option B, what happens next?

The natural question after a refi is: "I got most of my capital back — so what's still working for me?" The answer is your ownership stake. You sold none of the property. You took out a bigger loan against it, returned that cash to investors tax-free, and you still own your share of the deal.

From year 6 onward, three things keep compounding on a smaller capital base: (1) rent continues coming in and paying down the new (larger) mortgage, (2) the property continues to appreciate, and (3) you receive your pro-rata share of cash flow until the eventual sale.

Modeled at year 10 sale: a $25K investor who refi'd at year 5 ends up with ~$91,560 total across cash flow, refi proceeds, and exit — vs. ~$52,600 if they had sold at year 5. The refi path delivers roughly 75% more dollars over the same horizon because capital stayed deployed longer on a leveraged asset that kept growing.

Target IRR vs. the stock market

The cleanest way to compare investments is annualized return. Below, our target investor IRR against SPY's long-run historical performance.

SPY
S&P 500 — long-run historical annualized return
10.5%
Eidnani Capital LP
Target investor IRR over 5–7 year hold
~22%

NOTE:   SPY's 10.5% is realized over decades. Our ~22% is a target, not a guarantee. The structural argument for outperformance is leverage, tax shelter from depreciation, and the optionality of refinance. The actual gap will compress in years where appreciation is muted and widen in years where it isn't.

Important context

Faulkner Court is a real property in our personal portfolio, not a current offering. The numbers above are illustrative projections showing how the deal economics would work — not a guarantee of future returns on any sponsored deal. Equity gains shown elsewhere on this site are unrealized mark-to-market; no property has been sold or refinanced to date. Sponsored deals will follow the same structural framework — 7.5% pref, 80/20 split, 10%+ sponsor co-invest — but will vary in specifics. The 4% annual appreciation and 3% rent growth used here are conservative; macro factors discussed elsewhere may support outperformance, but actual results in any given deal may be higher or lower. See FAQ for a frank discussion of realistic downside scenarios. Past performance does not predict future results.

08 · Frequently asked

Questions investors actually ask.

What does the investment process look like?
Four steps. (1) Intro conversation — 30–45 minute call to walk through strategy, buy box, and the operating portfolio. No deal pitch, just a relationship conversation. (2) Join the investor list — you receive periodic market updates and portfolio commentary, no commitment. (3) Deal-specific offering — when a property fits the buy box, list members receive the full offering memorandum: property details, underwriting, projections, sponsor commitment, and subscription window. (4) Subscribe and fund — review with your advisors, sign subscription docs, wire funds. Each deal is its own LLC. Quarterly distributions, deal updates, and tax documents come directly to you.
What is the minimum investment?
$10,000 is the standard minimum, with a stated preference for investments of $25,000 or more. Specific minimums for any given deal are disclosed in that deal's offering documents and may vary based on the size of the raise.
How long is my capital locked up?
Real estate is illiquid. Plan on a 5–7 year hold per deal. There is no secondary market for your interest, and early redemption is generally not available. We treat this as a feature, not a bug — long holds compound.
How do distributions work?
Operating cash flow is distributed quarterly after debt service, expenses, and reserves. The 7.5% preferred return is paid first; profits above the pref are split 80/20 between investors and sponsor. Capital event proceeds (sale or refinance) are distributed per the same waterfall.
How am I taxed?
Each deal is structured as a pass-through LLC, so you pay tax personally rather than the LLC paying first.

What you'll receive each year: a Schedule K-1 (typically delivered in March), which reports your share of income, deductions, depreciation, and capital events. You hand the K-1 to your CPA along with your other tax documents — they incorporate it into your federal and state returns. There's no separate filing on your end.

Why this is favorable: real estate generates depreciation — a non-cash deduction that reduces your reported taxable income from the deal even when actual cash distributions are positive. In practice, this often means investors receive distribution checks during the hold while showing little or no taxable income from the LP for tax purposes. The full benefit varies by your tax situation (passive activity rules, basis, etc.).

At sale or refinance: capital gains and depreciation recapture are reported on the K-1 in the year of the event. Refinance proceeds are loan proceeds, not income, and are generally not taxable when received.

This isn't tax advice — your CPA needs to apply it to your specific situation. But the practical workflow is simple: receive K-1, hand to CPA, file as usual.
Do I need to be an accredited investor?
Not necessarily. Offerings are made under Reg D 506(b), which permits a limited number of sophisticated non-accredited investors with a pre-existing substantive relationship to the sponsor. Specific eligibility is confirmed during the subscription process.
What could go wrong?
Honest answer: a lot of things, in roughly this order of likelihood.

Operationally: tenants leave or stop paying, repairs come in higher than reserved, property tax assessments jump, insurance premiums climb. These are normal real estate operating risks — they reduce cash flow but rarely threaten principal. We reserve 4% for maintenance and 3% for vacancy on every deal precisely to absorb these.

Structurally: rates stay elevated longer than expected, making refinances harder; rent growth flattens; appreciation comes in below model; a regional downturn hits one of our markets. In any of these cases, distributions get reduced or paused, and the deal still works on cash flow but exit timing slides.

Financially (rare but real): a forced sale at the wrong moment in the cycle could result in partial principal loss. Total loss of principal is uncommon for properly insured, properly structured residential — it would typically require an uninsured catastrophic event or sponsor fraud.

Across all of these: we mitigate via conservative leverage (80% LTV max), fixed-rate financing only, full insurance coverage, 10%+ sponsor co-invest on every deal, and conservative underwriting assumptions. None of this eliminates risk — it just calibrates it honestly. If you want zero principal risk, this is the wrong asset class.
Why invest with you instead of buying my own rental property?
Honest answer: it depends on what you want. Both are legitimate paths.

Buying your own rental works better if: you want direct control over which property to buy, you have the time and inclination to manage tenants and contractors (or hire and oversee a PM yourself), you want all the cash flow and tax benefits, and you can put $50K-100K+ down on a single property. The upside is you keep 100% of the economics. The downside is you take 100% of the operational load — tenant calls, midnight repairs, eviction headaches, paperwork.

Investing through us works better if: you want exposure to cash-flowing residential without the operational overhead, you want a smaller minimum check ($10K vs. $50K-100K down for a property), you want diversification across multiple deals and markets over time, you want professional underwriting and ongoing reporting, and you want the tax benefits (depreciation passes through K-1) without the active participation.

The real tradeoff is control vs. leverage of someone else's time. Direct ownership gives you control. Investing with us gives you leverage on our underwriting, deal flow, and operations. We're not necessarily a better deal in absolute terms — but for most professionals with day jobs, the after-tax, after-time return on a sponsored deal usually beats trying to do it yourself. We'd rather you do the math honestly and pick what fits your life.
Who manages the properties day-to-day?
We work with vetted local property management firms in each market — typically firms we have personal operating experience with. Sponsor oversight is hands-on: weekly check-ins, monthly financials, quarterly investor reporting.
How do I track my investment?
You receive a personalized shared folder with all your deal documents, signed agreements, and tax forms. Quarterly written updates cover deal-level performance and distributions. An annual investor letter recaps the year. Direct access to the principal — questions get answered the same week.

Have a question? Want to talk?

Eidnani Capital works with a small circle of family, friends, and trusted relationships. If that includes you — or you think it might — reach out. No pitch, just a conversation.

Get in touch →
arnav@eidnanirealty.com